Waist size beats BMI at predicting death risk, Nature study finds (opens the source in a new tab)

Explainer: records of 800,000 people show a waist-based obesity test predicts death risk better than BMI; what changes and what the study found.
Original graphic: KKReckonsView full size ↗
  • A study in Nature, using records of more than 800,000 people in China, Spain, the UK and the US, found that an obesity definition adding waist size and other body-fat measures to BMI predicts death risk better than BMI alone.
  • The new test classed an extra 5–9% of people as obese whom BMI calls merely overweight, and moved 1–3% the other way. Those flagged obese by BMI alone had no extra risk of death.
  • It splits obesity into 'clinical', with at least one of 18 linked illnesses such as heart failure, and 'preclinical'. One critic warns waist checks may make routine visits harder for patients.
5–9%
more people classed as obese

Why it matters BMI cut-offs decide who gets treatment, and the study's lead author says sicker patients were denied surgery for missing the threshold. A test that tracks real risk could steer care to the people who need it.

Other side BMI's strength is its simplicity: a scale and a height are enough. More measurements mean more time and discomfort in a routine visit, and records-based studies show who is at risk, not yet whether changing the definition improves outcomes.

Read the full 18 Nov edition →Catch up on past editions

Today’s edition is ready

Read deep. Think clearly. Stay curious.

A daily visual briefing on the stories that matter: India, the world, and what’s next.

Read Today’s Edition →Get it by email ↗

Free · 55 editions and 390 stories so far · Unsubscribe anytime

Emails are sent by beehiiv; your address is used only for this newsletter. Privacy · Editorial standards